Which Dog Food is Better? – Happy pets guide

iHeartDogs is reader supported. Some of the links below may be paid affiliate links, where we receive a small commission on a product at no additional cost to you.

Choosing the right food for your pet can feel like navigating a culinary labyrinth. With an overwhelming array of options, it’s crucial to be informed about the differences among leading brands. This article dives into an in-depth comparison between two of the most popular pet food brands on the market today – Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan. From ingredient quality to dietary specifics, we’ll dissect what each has to offer, helping you make an informed decision for your furry friend’s nutrition.

Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan: An Ingredient Comparison

The debate over the best nutritional options for our pets is a hot topic among pet parents. Two popular brands at the center of this discussion are Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan. Both brands are reputable and provide a variety of products tailored to different stages of a pet’s life, breed size, and health conditions. But how do they fare when it comes to their ingredient quality and composition? Let’s compare.

Primary Ingredients

Blue Buffalo often emphasizes their use of real meat as the primary ingredient in their formulas. This includes high-quality protein sources like deboned chicken, turkey, and fish. The focus on lean proteins helps contribute to healthy muscle development and maintenance in pets.

Purina Pro Plan, on the other hand, also lists real meat as the primary ingredient in many of their products. However, Purina Pro Plan may also utilize meat by-product meals (such as poultry by-product meal) more frequently than Blue Buffalo, which some pet parents might see as a less desirable source of protein.

Grains and Gluten

Blue Buffalo products are often marketed as grain-free, appealing to pet owners who are concerned about potential allergies or food sensitivities their pets might have to grains. It’s important to note, though, that most pets do not require a grain-free diet and some recent research has raised questions about a potential link between grain-free diets and certain heart conditions in dogs.

Purina Pro Plan, on the other hand, incorporates grains such as corn, wheat, and barley in some of their formulas. These grains, which are not necessarily harmful to pets, provide a source of carbohydrates, which are essential for energy.

Fruits and Vegetables

Blue Buffalo incorporates a blend of fruits and vegetables into their formulas, offering a variety of micronutrients. Their proprietary “LifeSource Bits,” which are cold-formed to preserve nutrient potency, contain a precise blend of antioxidants, vitamins, and minerals selected by veterinarians and animal nutritionists.

Purina Pro Plan formulas also include vegetables and fruits, though their inclusion may not be as prominently marketed. However, the brand does fortify their products with vitamins, minerals, and probiotics for digestive health and immune support.

Specialty Diets

Both brands offer products for specialty diets, including weight management, sensitive stomach, breed size, age-specific, and more. Blue Buffalo’s line includes grain-free options and products with novel proteins for pets with specific dietary needs.

Purina Pro Plan has an extensive range of specialty diet options too, notably their veterinary diet line that addresses specific health issues such as kidney function, diabetes management, and more.

Recall History: Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan

When it comes to choosing a dog food, one of the most important factors to consider is the company’s recall history. A recall means that the food has been found to be unsafe for dogs to eat, and it can be a sign of quality control problems.

Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan are two of the most popular dog food brands, but they have very different recall histories. Blue Buffalo has had a total of 3 recalls since 2016, while Purina Pro Plan has only had 1 recall.

The most recent Blue Buffalo recall was in March 2017, when the company recalled a batch of canned dog food due to the possibility of high levels of beef thyroid hormone. The other two Blue Buffalo recalls were in 2016, for a batch of Life Protection Formula Dog Food that contained excessive moisture and mold, and for a batch of Blue Divine Delights and Blue Wilderness Trail Trays that had quality issues with the foil seals on the top of the cups.

The only Purina Pro Plan recall was in March 2016, when the company recalled select lots of its Beneful and Purina Pro Plan wet dog foods because they might not have contained the recommended level of vitamins and minerals.

Based on their recall histories, Purina Pro Plan has a much cleaner record than Blue Buffalo. This suggests that Purina Pro Plan has more thorough quality control procedures in place. If you are concerned about the safety of your dog’s food, then Purina Pro Plan may be a better choice than Blue Buffalo.

However, it is important to note that both Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan are reputable brands that produce high-quality dog food. The decision of which brand to choose ultimately comes down to your individual preferences and budget.

Blue Buffalo vs Purina Pro Plan: Which Food is More Affordable?

Affordability

When it comes to affordability, Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan are both relatively expensive brands. However, there is a slight difference in price between the two brands.

In general, Blue Buffalo is slightly more expensive than Purina Pro Plan. This is likely due to the fact that Blue Buffalo uses more natural ingredients in its food. However, it is important to note that there is a wide range of prices within both brands, so you can find affordable options if you shop around.

Here is a table comparing the prices of some popular Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan dog foods:

Conclusion

Based on the prices of some popular dog foods, Purina Pro Plan is slightly more affordable than Blue Buffalo. However, there is a wide range of prices within both brands, so you can find affordable options if you shop around. Ultimately, the decision of which brand to choose comes down to your individual preferences and budget.

Additional Factors to Consider

In addition to price, there are other factors to consider when choosing a dog food, such as the quality of the ingredients, the nutritional content, and the taste. It is important to do your research and choose a food that is right for your dog’s individual needs.

Which brand uses more real meat in their recipes, Blue Buffalo or Purina Pro Plan?Both Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan utilize real meat as a primary ingredient in many of their formulas. However, Blue Buffalo emphasizes this aspect more, while Purina Pro Plan may use meat by-products more frequently in their formulas.
Do both brands offer grain-free options?Yes, both brands offer grain-free options. Blue Buffalo emphasizes grain-free recipes more, while Purina Pro Plan includes grains in some of their formulas.
Are Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan suitable for pets with specific dietary needs?Absolutely. Both brands offer a variety of specialized diets for pets with specific needs such as weight management, sensitive stomachs, or breed-size specific nutrition.
Which brand is more cost-effective, Blue Buffalo or Purina Pro Plan?Typically, Purina Pro Plan is a more cost-effective choice. However, prices can vary based on the specific formula, bag size, and where you purchase the food.
Does either brand use artificial preservatives, colors, or flavors?Both brands strive to avoid artificial preservatives, colors, and flavors. Always check the ingredient list for any specific product to ensure it meets your standards.
Are there puppy-specific formulas available from Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan?Yes, both brands offer formulas specifically tailored to puppies’ nutritional needs.
Which brand is better for senior dogs, Blue Buffalo or Purina Pro Plan?Both brands offer formulas designed for senior dogs. The “better” brand will depend on your pet’s specific nutritional needs and any potential health issues, so consult with your vet.
Are Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan AAFCO approved?Yes, both brands formulate their pet foods to meet or exceed the nutritional standards established by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO).
Do Blue Buffalo and Purina Pro Plan have breed-specific formulas?Both brands offer breed-size specific formulas, such as large breed and small breed options. However, they do not typically offer breed-specific formulas (e.g., for German Shepherds or Poodles).
Do either Blue Buffalo or Purina Pro Plan offer wet food options?